The intimate connection of trust and corporation : Constraints on the exercise of the constitutional amendment power in managed investment schemes
Ranero, FJ (1999) The intimate connection of trust and corporation : Constraints on the exercise of the constitutional amendment power in managed investment schemes. Research Master thesis, University of Tasmania.
The objectives of this thesis are twofold. The^r^í and primary objective is the identification of
the most appropriate doctrinal approach which courts must adopt in reviewing exercises of the
constitutional amendment power in managed investment schemes. The second objective is to
evaluate the adequacy of the applicable law in protecting the legitimate rights and interests of
the scheme participants. The discussion further provides a medium upon which various
underlying themes are explored. These themes include the nature of judicial review upon abuse
of power generally by both fiduciaries and non-fiduciaries, the analogy between corporations
and managed investment schemes, and the division of power between the two primary scheme
organs, being the responsible entity and scheme members in a general meeting.
Managed investment schemes are investment arrangements in which participants forgo control
over their capital contributions in consideration for a bundle of rights, derived from the
Corporations Law, the scheme constitution as a commercial contract, and the law of equity.
Neither the contractual nor the equitable rights of members are indefeasible, as the scheme
constitution may be amended, either unilaterally by the responsible entity, or by a special
resolution of scheme members.
Exercises of the constitutional amendment power are subject to various restraints, similarly
derived from legislation, contract and equity. In relation to unilateral amendments, the
Corporations Law provides that an amendment can only be effected where the responsible
entity reasonably considers the amendment will not adversely affect members' rights.
Restraints are also imposed by equity, such as the responsible entity's obHgation to exercise its
powers for a proper purpose, being based on the equitable doctrine oí fraud on the power.
Further equitable restraints placed on the responsible entity are drawn from its position as
trustee of the scheme assets, such as the requirement that it act in the best interests of scheme
members and treat them impartially. Amendments by members' resolution are similarly open
to judicial review based on equitable obligations drawn from a company law context, being
namely the requirement that the amendment not involve afraud on the minority.
The adequacy of the above restraints is judged both by applying the identified law to various
hypothetical amendment which may be instigated by scheme participants, as well as by way of
a comparative analysis with the protection afforded to company shareholders. It is concluded
that the interplay between exphcit statutory controls and the various equitable obligations
provides the appropriate balance between investor protection and allowing sufficient flexibility
in order to facihtate the efficient commercial operation of the scheme.
|Item Type:||Thesis (Research Master)|
|Additional Information:||Copyright the Author - The University is continuing to endeavour to trace the copyright owner(s) and in the meantime this item has been reproduced here in good faith. We would be pleased to hear from the copyright owner(s).
|Deposited By:||UTAS ePrints Officer|
|Deposited On:||18 Jul 2011 12:00|
|Last Modified:||02 Sep 2012 15:19|
|ePrint Statistics:||View statistics for this ePrint|
Repository Staff Only: item control page