Please Note:

The Library Open Repository will be moving to a new authentication system on the 1st of November.

From this date onwards, account holders will be required to login using their University of Tasmania credentials.
If your current repository username differs from your University username, please email E.Prints@utas.edu.au so we can update these details on your behalf.

Due to the change, there will be a short outage of the repository from 9am on the morning of the 1st of November

Library Open Repository

Rebuttal to Froesea and Proelss ‘Evaluation and legal assessment of certified seafood’’

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Agnew, D J and Gutierrez, N L and Stern-Pirlot, A and Smith, ADM and Zimmerman, C and Sainsbury, K J (2012) Rebuttal to Froesea and Proelss ‘Evaluation and legal assessment of certified seafood’’. Marine Policy: The International Journal of Ocean Affairs, 38. pp. 551-553. ISSN 0308-597X

[img] PDF
Agnew_Rebuttal_...pdf | Request a copy
Full text restricted
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.

Abstract

In arecentpaper,FroeseandProelss [1] contendthat31%ofstockstargetedbyMarineStewardship
Council(MSC)certifiedfisheriesareoverfishedandsubjecttoongoingoverfishingandafurther8%are
either overfishedorsubjecttooverfishing.Theirresultsarederivedusingadefinitionof‘overfished’
that isnotconsistentwithinternationallyaccepteddefinitionsandinterpretations.Inaddition,the
authorsusedunrealisticestimatesofbiomassthatproduceMaximumSustainableYields(BMSY)
obtainedthroughmethodsthatareinconsistentwiththeapproachusedbythemanagementagencies
and scientificadvisorybodiesresponsibleforthestocksinquestion.
AnalysessuchasthatpublishedbyFroeseandProelssareanimportantpartoftheexternal,
independentscrutinyoftheprogrammethatMSCwelcomes.Howeverthereareanumberofserious
flaws intheiranalysis,dataandresultingconclusionsthatthisresponseseekstocorrect.Usingdatafor
45 stocksexploitedbyMSCcertifiedfisheries(460% oftotalfisheriesintheprogrammeand 480% of
total certifiedcatch),internationallyacceptedmethodsfordeterminingMSYreferencepoints,and
internationallyaccepteddefinitionsoftheterms‘overfished’and‘overfishing’,nostocksexploitedby
MSC certifiedfisheriescanbedefinedasoverfished(belowtheirlimitreferencepoints).

Item Type: Article
Keywords: Certification Marine Stewardship Council Sustainable stocks
Journal or Publication Title: Marine Policy: The International Journal of Ocean Affairs
Page Range: pp. 551-553
ISSN: 0308-597X
Identification Number - DOI: org/10.1016/j.marpol.2012.07.002
Additional Information:

Copyright 2012 Elsevier

Date Deposited: 03 Dec 2013 04:51
Last Modified: 18 Nov 2014 04:56
Item Statistics: View statistics for this item

Actions (login required)

Item Control Page Item Control Page
TOP