creators_name: Yu, H
creators_id: H.Yu@utas.edu.au
type: article
datestamp: 2008-06-11 03:18:39
lastmod: 2008-07-18 10:59:45
metadata_visibility: show
title: From active audience to media citizenship: The case
of Post-Mao China
ispublished: pub
subjects: 420304
full_text_status: restricted
keywords: Active audience; media storyteller; media citizenship; Internet; journalism; minoritized community; Sun Zhigang; Li Siyi
note: The definitive version is available online at 
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/content?
abstract: This article studies media practices of urban Chinese in order to examine conceptual changes in the notion of citizenship in post-Mao China. It focuses on how the media can cultivate a “rights” consciousness among the populace and how new media have been appropriated as alternative public spaces for articulating alternative political discourses. Through two case studies (the deaths of Sun Zhigang and Li Siyi), I argue that the concept of citizenship can no longer be thought of as a formal and institutional given, but as a concept of fluidity and flexibility that rests on the spatial and subjective positions of the individual in question. New media have been playing an essential role in decentralizing “citizenship.” Active audience participation in online discussions, petitions and protests can influence public opinion, check the authority, and even challenge the political agendas of the government as shown in the abolition of “anti-vagrancy laws” in the case studies. I describe this as the practice of “media citizenship.” It is a sign of empowerment for the awakening “masses” of certain factions of Chinese society for whom participation in the circulation of “lay” knowledge of social and political issues is equivalent to exercising citizenship.
date: 2006-06
date_type: published
publication: Social Semiotics
volume: 16
number: 2
pagerange: 303-326
id_number: 10.1080/10350330600664888
refereed: TRUE
issn: 1035-0330
official_url: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10350330600664888
referencetext: . (2002) State control of the Internet in China.. — November [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
2. Ang, I. (1991) Desperately seeking the audience Routledge , New York [your library's links] [your library's links] 
3. (2003a) “Cong sansui ntong Li Siyi de beiju kan zhidu de queshi yu mibu” [“On defects of the system and its remedies from the tragedy of three-year-old-girl Li Siyi”]. — Online posting [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
4. (2003b) “Weishenmo women you zui que wuchu shuo” [“Why cannot we find a place to speak when we've got mouths”]. — Online posting [accessed 25 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
5. (2003c) Untitled online posting. — [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
6. Barboza, D. (2005) Pushing (and toeing) the line in China. — New York Times, 18 April [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
7. Barnett, C. (2003) Culture and democracy: Media, space, and representation Edinburgh University Press , Edinburgh [your library's links] [your library's links] 
8. Chan, A. (2002) From propaganda to hegemony: Jiaodian Fangtan and China's media policy. Journal of Contemporary China 11:30 , pp. 35-51. [your library's links] [your library's links] [informaworld] 
9. (2003) China's new vagrancy regulation comes into effect,. — 1 August [accessed 5 January 2004]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
10. (2004) Chinese internet user profile. — [accessed 8 September 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
11. Chomsky, N. (1989) Necessary illusions: Thought control in democratic societies South End , Boston, Mass [your library's links] [your library's links] 
12. Dayan, D. and Katz, E. (1992) Media event: The live broadcasting of history Harvard University Press , Cambridge, Mass. and London [your library's links] [your library's links] 
13. Du, X. (1999) Internet adoption and usage in China. — Paper presented at the 27th Annual Telecommunications Policy and Research Conference, Alexandria, VA, 25-27 September [accessed 8 September 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
14. Feng, Y. (2004) “Meiyou ren xingmian yu zui—xuezhe Kang Xiaoguang diaocha Li Siyi er si shijian zifei chushu” [“No one is exonerative—Scholar Kang Xiaoguang Investigate the Incident of Li Siyi and Publish a Book at his own cost”]. — Online posting, 28 August [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
15. Friedman, E. (1995) National identity and democratic prospects in socialist China M.E. Sharpe , Armonk and London [your library's links] [your library's links] 
16. Ganley, G. D. (1992) The exploding political power of personal media Ablex Publishing Corporation , Norwood, N.J [your library's links] [your library's links] 
17. Garnham, Garnham. (1995) The media and the narratives of the intellectual. Media, Culture and Society 17 , pp. 359-384. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
18. Garnham, N. (2000) Emancipation, the media, and modernity Oxford University Press , Oxford [your library's links] [your library's links] 
19. Giese, K. (Hughes, C. R. and Wacker, G. eds.) (2003) China and the Internet: Politics of the digital leap forward RoutledgeCurzon , London and New York [your library's links] [your library's links] 
20. Goldman, M. (2005) The role of China's public intellectuals at the start of the twenty-first century. — Roundtable on “Public Intellectuals in China” by Congressional-Executive Commission on China, 10 March [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
21. Grosswiler, P. (1998) Historical hopes, media fears, and the electronic town meeting concept: Where technology meets democracy or demagogy?. Journal of Communication Inquiry 22:2 , p. 133. [your library's links] [your library's links] [ crossref ] 
22. Guo, L. (2002) China and the Internet, a game of cat and mouse?. — [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
23. Han, F. and Tang, J. (2003) “Li Siyi—weile siwang bubei yiwang” [“Li Siyi—never forget her death”]. — China News Weekly, 19 December. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
24. Hang, F. (2003) 17 tian wangluo jieli jinshi. — [“17-day online fasting relay”]. Online posting [accessed 20 December 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
25. Harwit, E. and Clark, D. (2001) Shaping the Internet in China: Evolution of political control over network infrastructure and content. Asian Survey 41:3 , pp. 377-408. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
26. He, Z. (Lee, Chin-Chuan ed.) (2000) Power, money, and media: Communication patterns and bureaucratic control in cultural China Northwestern University Press , Evanston, Ill [your library's links] [your library's links] 
27. (Huang, S. and Zhou, Y. eds.) (2003) Zhongguo chuanmei shichang da bian ju Citic Publishing House , Beijing — [Total Transformations of Chinese media market] [your library's links] [your library's links] 
28. Kang, X. (2004) “Qisu—weile Li Siyi de beiju bu zai chong yan” [“Bringing a suit—The tragedy of Li Siyi cannot recur”]. — [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
29. Keane, J. (1995) Structural transformation of the public sphere. Communication Review 1 , pp. 1-22. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
30. Lee, C. C. (Lee, C. C. ed.) (1990) Voices of China: The interplay of politics and journalism Guilford Publications , New York [your library's links] [your library's links] 
31. Leng, X. (2003) “Zhongguo 12 chengshi hulianwang shiyong zhuangkuang ji yingxiang diaocha baogao fabu” [“The Release of Report on the Survey of Internet Usage and Influence of 12 Cities in China”]. — [accessed 9 November 2003]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
32. Li, X. (2002) “Focus” (Jiaodian Fangtan) and the changes in the Chinese television industry. Journal of Contemporary China 11:30 , pp. 17-34. [your library's links] [your library's links] [informaworld] 
33. Li, X. G. (Gan, S.,  Gomes, J. and Johannen, U. eds.) (2004) Asian cyberactivism: Freedom of expression and media censorship Fredrich Naumann Foundation, East and Southeast Asian Regional Office , Bangkok [your library's links] [your library's links] 
34. Li, Y. (2003a) “Gong'an zhua zou muqing qie bu tongzhi jiashu, 3 sui you nu huohuo er si jia zhong” [“Police arrested mother without notifying relatives, 3-year-old girl starved to death at home”]. — [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
35. Li, Y. (2003b) “Bei suo jia zhong 3 sui you n can si” [“Locked indoors a 3-year-old girl died tragically”]. — [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
36. Lull, J. (1991) China turned on: Television, reform, and resistance Routledge , London and New York [your library's links] [your library's links] 
37. Ma, E. K. (Curran, J. and Park, M. J. eds.) (2000) De-westernizing media studies Routledge , London and New York [your library's links] [your library's links] [informaworld] 
38. Martindill, K. (2003) Control of the Internet in China. — China Digital News [accessed 8 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
39. Morley, D. (2003) What's “home” got to do with it? Contradictory dynamics in the domestication of technology and the dislocation of domesticity. European Journal of Cultural Studies 6:4 , pp. 435-458. [your library's links] [your library's links] [ crossref ] 
40. (2005) Internet filtering in China in 2004-2005: A country studies. — [accessed 14 May 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
41. Pan, Z. (Evanston, C. C. Lee. ed.) (2000) Improvising reform activities: The changing reality of journalistic practice in China. Power, money, and media: Communication patterns and bureaucratic control in cultural China Northwestern University Press , Illinois [your library's links] [your library's links] 
42. Pan, Z. and Lu, Y. (Lee, C. C. ed.) (2003) Localizing professionalism: Discursive practices in China's media reforms. Chinese media, global context RoutledgeCurzon , London and New York [your library's links] [your library's links] 
43. (2003) Beijing protects minors through legislation. — People's Daily [your library's links] [your library's links] 
44. Perry, E. J. and Selden, M. (2003) Chinese society: Change, conflict and resistance Routledge , London and New York [your library's links] [your library's links] 
45. Polumbaum, J. (2001) China's media: Between politics and the market. Current History 100:647 , pp. 269-277. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
46. Shao, D. (2003) “Huanying hulianwang shi de minzhu de shehui shiyan” [“Welcome the social test of Internet democracy”]. — Online posting [accessed 9 November 2003]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
47. Sheller, M. and Urry, J. (2003) Mobile transformations of “public” and “private” life. Theory, Culture & Society 20:3 , pp. 107-125. [your library's links] [your library's links] [ crossref ] 
48. Shu, T. (2003a) “Guanzhu Li Siyi zhi si (si) shi sheng you shi shen de meiti” [“On the death of Li Siyi 4—Media muted and raped”]. — Online posting [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
49. Shu, T. (2003b) “Guanzhu Li Siyi zhi si (yi) bu neng yi 'cangying' xunzang” [“On the death of Li Siyi 1: 'Flies' should not be buried alive”]. — Online posting [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
50. (2003a) “Yi daxuesheng yin wu zaizhu zheng bei shourong bing zao tuda zhishi” [“A university graduate detained and cruelly beaten to death for not showing his temporary resident card”]. — Southern Metropolitan News. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
51. (2003b) “Pinglun: shui wei yige gongmin de fei zhengchang siwang fuze” [“Commentary: who is/are responsible for the unnatural death of a citizen”]. — Southern Metropolitan News. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
52. (2003c) “Sun zhigang an zuori kaishen, yangshi yaoqing falu zhuanjia tantao anjian” [“Trial of Sun Zhigang case yesterday, law experts invited to discuss case on CCTV”]. — Southern Metropolitan News. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
53. Spigel, L. (2001) Welcome to the dreamhouse Duke University Press , Durham, N.C [your library's links] [your library's links] 
54. Xiao, S. (2003) “Ping Sun Zhigang an: ziwo diaocha weibei chengxu zhengyi” [“Comments on the case of Sun Zhigang: Self-investigation is a breach of procedural justice”]. — Online posting [accessed 9 November 2003]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
55. Williams, R. (1974) Television: Technology and cultural form Fontana , London [your library's links] [your library's links] 
56. Wong, B. (2002a) China's Internet ban expands to part of Yahoo! Search engine. Digital Freedom Network — 11 September [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
57. Wong, B. (2002b) Chinese student detained for publishing articles online. Digital Freedom Network — 10 December [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
58. Wong, B. (2003) New study finds Chinese users believe Internet will improve the world. — [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
59. Wong, B. (2004) The tug-of-war for control of China's Internet. — [accessed 20 April 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
60. Yang, G. (2003) The Internet and the rise of a transnational Chinese cultural sphere. Media, Culture and Society 25:4 , pp. 469-490. [your library's links] [your library's links] [ crossref ] 
61. Yu, H. (2004) The power of thumbs: The politics of SMS in urban China. Journal of Asia-Pacific Studies 2:2 , pp. 31-44. [your library's links] [your library's links] 
62. Yu, H. (2006) Talking, linking, clicking: The politics of AIDS and SARS in urban China. Positions: East Asia Cultures Critique — 15 [your library's links] [your library's links] 
63. Yu, H. (Berry, C. and Zhu, Y. eds.) (2007) TV China Indiana University Press , Indianapolis [your library's links] [your library's links] 
64. Zeng, Y. (2003) “Wo de diyi di xinwen lei” [“My first teardrop for news”]. — Online posting (29 June) [accessed 20 December 2005]. Available from: [your library's links] [your library's links] 
65. Zhang, Y. (2000) From masses to audience: Changing media ideologies and practices in reform China. Journalism Studies 1:4 , pp. 617-635. [your library's links] [your library's links] [informaworld] 
66. Zhao, Y. (1998) Media, market, and democracy in China: Between the party line and the bottom line University of Illinois Press , Urbana and Chicago, Ill [your library's links] [your library's links] 
67. Zhao, Y. (2000) From commercialization to conglomeration: The transformation of the Chinese press within the orbit of the party state. Journal of Communication Spring , pp. 3-26. [your library's links] [your library's links] [ crossref ] 
68. Zhou, Y. (2000) Watchdogs on party leashes? Contexts and implications of investigative journalism in post-Deng China. Journalism Studies 1:2 , pp. 577-597. [your library's links] [your library's links]
citation: Yu, H (2006) From active audience to media citizenship: The case of Post-Mao China. Social Semiotics, 16 (2). pp. 303-326. ISSN 1035-0330
document_url: http://eprints.utas.edu.au/6537/1/media_citizenship.pdf