Open Access Repository

Establishing the value of an integrated geochemistry-mineralogy-texture approach for acid rock drainage prediction


Downloads per month over past year

Parbhakar-Fox, AK 2012 , 'Establishing the value of an integrated geochemistry-mineralogy-texture approach for acid rock drainage prediction', PhD thesis, University of Tasmania.

PDF (Front matter)
front-parbhakar...pdf | Download (109kB)
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.

PDF (Whole thesis excluding appendices)
whole-parbhakar...pdf | Download (8MB)
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.

[img] Archive | Download (47MB)
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.

[img] Archive | Request a copy
Full text restricted
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.


The total estimated cost for worldwide liability associated with current and future ARD (acid rock drainage)
remediation is approximately US $100 billion (Tremblay and Hogan, 2001 in Hudson-Edwards et al.,
2011). Such liabilities are partly due to the limitations of existing predictive protocols, highlighting the
importance of using appropriate and accurate methodologies. Current protocols for ARD risk assessment
follow the wheel approach (Morin and Hutt, 1998) or the AMIRA P387A Handbook (Smart et al., 2002).
However, the accuracy of these protocols solely relies on geochemical tests and, there is a clear absence
of detailed mineralogical and textural characterisation in the applied methodologies. Consequently,
inappropriate decisions can be made, either by not allocating the necessary resources when the ARD risk
is underestimated, or by wrongly not pursuing development when ARD risk overestimated. Therefore, an
improved predictive methodology based on ARD characteristics must be developed and implemented at
early-stages of the mine life cycle. Additionally, such a methodology should have applications at historic
mine sites to identify acid forming samples and guide site rehabilitation strategies.
The potential for improvement in ARD prediction methodology needs to consider mineralogical
and textural characteristics as well as geochemical analyses. Therefore, this thesis has developed an
improved and integrated protocol for classifying solid mine waste in terms of acid forming potential. The
geochemistry-mineralogy-texture, or GMT approach, consists of three stages which involve a parallel use
of geochemical, mineralogical and textural analyses:
• Stage-one: Low-cost pre-screening geochemical, mineralogical and textural tests and evaluations are
performed on the largest number of samples.
• Stage-two: Routine geochemical tests are performed on fewer samples, using more expensive tests.
• Stage-three: Advanced geochemical tests and microanalytical techniques are performed on well
selected samples.
Results are cross-checked at the end of each stage to provide an accurate sample classification in terms of
acid forming potential. The advantage of the proposed GMT methodology relative to those currently
used (e.g., the wheel approach, AMIRA P387A Handbook) is its structured approach, as evaluations of
problematic samples are focused upon, thereby increasing technical accuracy of predictions, and reducing
total number of samples analysed by routine tests, and overall costs. The acid rock drainage index (ARDI)
forms part of the GMT approach as a stage-one test, and was developed to evaluate intact rock texture in
terms of five key parameters (A: sulphide contents; B: sulphide alteration; C : sulphide morphology; D:
content of neutralising minerals; and E: sulphide mineral associations), which influence acid formation.
The GMT approach was tested on waste material from the historic Croydon gold-lode mines, and drill core samples from the operational Ernest Henry iron-oxide copper gold (IOCG) deposit, both located in
Queensland, Australia. The geology (including style of mineralisation and texture) differed between the
two sites, allowing for critical assessment of both the GMT approach and the ARDI.
A mesotextural classification method (using geological logging, field portable X-Ray fluorescence
and short-wave Infrared techniques) for grouping waste materials was developed and tested at the historic
Croydon-gold mining operations. Through undertaking mesotextural classification, ten groups (A to J)
were identified, and systematically characterised by the GMT approach. At the end of stage-one, five
groups (C: porphyritic rhyolite containing disseminated pyrite in quartz veins; E: porphyritic rhyolite
containing disseminated pyrite in the groundmass; G: semi-massive quartz-sphalerite-galena-pyrite;
H: massive arsenopyrite-quartz; and J: semi-massive quartz- pyrite) were identified as potentially acid
forming and required stage-two testing. However, all samples were tested at stage-two to check the
accuracy of stage-one results, and were in agreement thus validating stage-one classifications. Samples
from mesotextural groups C, E, G, H and J were subjected to stage-three analyses which utilised
advanced geochemical tests, and microtextural analyses (i.e., mineral liberation analysis, laser ablation-
ICP-MS and scanning electron microscopy). Stage-three geochemical analyses demonstrated that NAG
testing results on samples containing <0.3 wt. % sulphide were inaccurate (i.e., underestimated acid
forming potential), with the multi-addition NAG test instead recommended for use. Microtextural
studies indicated that trace element distribution; contents of micro-inclusions and mineral association
were significant controls on sulphide oxidation. Final GMT approach classifications identified groups H
and J as extremely acid forming; and groups E and G as potentially acid forming.
Croydon waste materials representative of mesotextural groups E, G, H and J were selected for
thirty-week column leach kinetic testing following the recommendations of the GMT approach. Twelve
columns were established, with two size fractions (-10 mm and -4 mm) prepared from each sample,
to investigate the effects of grain size on pH, metal elution and secondary mineral precipitation. The
mineralogy and microtexture of the column feed material were examined routinely (i.e., every five weeks)
through quantitative X-Ray diffractometry, scanning electron microscopy and laser ablation ICP-MS
studies. These data were directly compared with leachate chemistry (pH, EC, SO4 and cation contents)
to identify the controls on sulphide oxidation and trace element liberation. Material representative of
mesotextural group H was the most acid forming, with lower pH values and higher cumulative mass
release of elements calculated for the -4 mm fraction. Mineralogical data showed progressive replacement
of arsenopyrite to trace element rich (i.e., Cu, Pb and Zn) scorodite. Pyrite in material representative
of mesotextural groups E and J was As-rich, with greater quantities of pyrite weathering products
(i.e., rhomboclase, jarosite, alunite) and textures identified over time. Generally, lower pH and higher
dissolved metals and arsenic were measured in leachate from the -4 mm fraction. Values of pH were
particularly sensitive to the development of fi ne hydrous ferric oxide coatings on pyrite in groups E and
J. Galena was also identified in material representative of groups E and J and was observed to weather
rapidly to anglesite over the duration of these tests. Whilst sphalerite present in material representative
of mesotextural group G was Cd- and Fe-rich and contained Cu micro-inclusions (factors which increase
oxidation rate), overall it was the least weathered of the sulphides. However, the leachate pH values
measured from group G indicated that this material is acid forming as a consequence of the oxidation of
pyrite which was also identified in this group. The highest cumulative mass release of Zn relative to the
other groups was measured from the -4 mm fraction. However, very low cumulative mass release rates of
Cd were calculated from both grain size fractions. Kinetic test results confirmed that mesotextural groups
G, H and J pose the greatest environmental risk in terms of ARD and potential metal/metalloid leaching.
Consequently, a rehabilitation strategy focusing on individual segregation and treatment of material
representative of groups G, H and J from non-acid forming mesotextural groups is recommended.
The application of geometallurgical techniques for predicting acid formation was demonstrated
using samples from the Ernest Henry IOCG deposit. Samples from two drill holes were initially subjected
to GMT analyses with results compared against geometallurgical data sets collected by mineral liberation
analysis (MLA), HyLogger and EQUOtip. Modal mineralogy data collected by MLA allowed for the
carbonate:sulphide ratio to be examined down hole as is required by stage-one of the GMT approach.
Relative carbonate contents determined from the HyLogger allowed for acid neutralising capacity
(ANC) values to be critically evaluated in terms of effective ANC. Finally, relationships between mineral
hardness measured using EQUOtip and lag-time to acid formation were identified. This study identifies
the potential for integrating geometallurgical techniques and data into the GMT approach, as a means
of allowing for ARD characterisation to be routinely undertaken at the early stages of mine operations.
Results from the two case study sites (Croydon, Ernest Henry) demonstrate that the geochemistry-mineralogy-
texture (GMT) approach represents a significant improvement to existing ARD predictive
protocols (e.g., the wheel approach, AMIRA P387A Handbook), by providing a structured methodology
to more efficiently identify problematic samples. Stage-one of the GMT approach allows best practice
sample numbers to be realistically achieved through cost-effective pre-screening tests, thus improving
ARD risk assessment. Furthermore, selection of samples for testing based on mesotextural grouping,
rather than lithology, allows for deposit wide ARD domaining to be effectively undertaken, particularly
when integrated with geometallurgical data. The presented methodology effectively integrates existing
geochemical tests with novel mineralogical and textural characterisation techniques. This in turn leads to
maximisation of knowledge, cost savings, and a more detailed characterisation of the most acid forming
samples. Therefore, the GMT approach represents a fundamental step-change in how ARD should be

Item Type: Thesis - PhD
Authors/Creators:Parbhakar-Fox, AK
Keywords: acid rock drainage, environment, mineralogy, geochemistry, texture, prediction, geology
Copyright Information:

Copyright 2012 the Author

Item Statistics: View statistics for this item

Actions (login required)

Item Control Page Item Control Page