Open Access Repository

Faked Depression: Comparing Malingering via the Internet, Pen-and-Paper, and Telephone Administration Modes

Hayes, J and Grieve, R 2013 , 'Faked Depression: Comparing Malingering via the Internet, Pen-and-Paper, and Telephone Administration Modes' , Telemedicine and E-health , pp. 714-716 , doi:

[img] PDF
Hayes__Grieve_(...pdf | Request a copy
Full text restricted
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.


Background: The Internet and telephone are valuable resources for mental health practitioners when access to face-to-face assessment or therapy is difficult. However, despite the high stakes (such as access to medication or financial compensation) often involved in psychological
testing, little is known about how test administration mode influences test scores when patients are malingering. The aim of this research was to examine for the first time the equivalence of a malingered measure of depression when administered over the Internet, over the telephone, and
with pen and paper. Subjects and Methods: A mixed experimental design was used with participants (n = 91) randomly allocated to Internet,telephone, or pen-and-paper groups. Participants completed the Edinburgh Depression Scale, first under standard instructions and then under instructions to fake as if experiencing severe depression. A manipulation check was included to ensure participants had understood and followed instructions to fake. Results: As predicted, participants were able to significantly increase their depression scores when asked to fake depression. Participants reported significantly lower faked depression
scores over the telephone than in pen-and-paper format. Faked depression scores in the online group did not differ significantly from those in the telephone and pen-and-paper groups. However, participants in all groups met criteria indicative of a provisional diagnosis of depression. Conclusions: Overall, the results indicate that there may be
no meaningful difference between malingering across administration modes. If an individual is malingering depression, administration mode has minimal influence. These findings provide preliminary support for the use of online/telephone technologies in the assessment of depression.

Item Type: Article
Authors/Creators:Hayes, J and Grieve, R
Journal or Publication Title: Telemedicine and E-health
DOI / ID Number:
Additional Information:

Copyright 2013 Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.

Item Statistics: View statistics for this item

Actions (login required)

Item Control Page Item Control Page