Open Access Repository

The ICJ Whaling Case: missed opportunity to advance the rule of law in resolving science-related disputes in global commons?


Downloads per month over past year

Gogarty, B ORCID: 0000-0002-9494-6598 and Lawrence, P ORCID: 0000-0003-3407-3446 2017 , 'The ICJ Whaling Case: missed opportunity to advance the rule of law in resolving science-related disputes in global commons?' , Heidelberg Journal of International Law, vol. 77, no. 1 , pp. 165-195 .

[img] PDF
116004_Gogarty ...pdf | Request a copy
Full text restricted


A number of treaties relating to the global commons include provisions which rely on science, or scientific research, without defining these terms (e.g. climate change, Antarctica). Disputes relating to what counts as genuine science and/or the appropriate responses to science are a feature of these regimes. Against this context, the Whaling Case before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) created hopes that the court would advance the rule of law by interpreting the concept of "scientific research" under the Whaling Convention. We argue that the court missed an opportunity by adopting a narrow approach which involved assessing the Japanese whaling programme in terms of its own objectives, by use of a standard of review test extracted from World Trade Organization (WTO) jurisprudence. On close inspection the ICJ implicitly adopted a definition of science while maintaining that it was doing no such thing. We argue that the Court should have proceeded to interpret scientific research under Art. VIII of the Whaling Convention applying the international law rules on treaty interpretation and informed by direct evidence from scientific experts which it is entitled to call on under its Statute. The Whaling Case thus represented a missed opportunity.

Item Type: Article
Authors/Creators:Gogarty, B and Lawrence, P
Keywords: whaling, Global Commons, The Rule of Law
Journal or Publication Title: Heidelberg Journal of International Law
Publisher: Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law
ISSN: 0044-2348
Copyright Information:

Copyright 2017 Heidelberg Journal of International Law

Related URLs:
Item Statistics: View statistics for this item

Actions (login required)

Item Control Page Item Control Page