Open Access Repository

Hypothesis disconfirmation : improving mock-juror sensitivity to confession evidence


Downloads per month over past year

Port, MEH 2018 , 'Hypothesis disconfirmation : improving mock-juror sensitivity to confession evidence', Honours thesis, University of Tasmania.

PDF (Whole thesis)
Port_whole_thes...pdf | Download (2MB)

| Preview


The present study investigated the extent to which mock-jurors are able to recognise factual inconsistencies in confession evidence. To assist this, a hypothesis disconfirmation intervention was trialled, as a method of improving sensitivity, and reducing judgements of guilt when a confession is unreliable (Brewer, Keast & Rishworth, 2002). Two hundred and eighty-three participants (197 female, 4 other; aged 18-78 years, `M` = 32.9, `SD` = 13.55) were randomly allocated to one of six conditions on the basis of variation in confession consistency, and the presence or
absence of the hypothesis disconfirmation. Content of confessions varied in consistency with police facts of the case across three conditions (consistent, small inconsistencies, large inconsistencies). After viewing a police report and confession statement, the hypothesis disconfirmation intervention required participants to generate alternative explanations for the suspect confessing, without having committed the crime; prior to provision of verdict. Results supported an error sensitivity perspective (cf. insensitivity perspective), which purports that jurors are better at recognising inconsistencies than previously acknowledged (Henderson & Levett, 2016; Palmer, Button, Barnett & Brewer, 2016; Woesetehoff & Meissner, 2016). Evidence for the hypothesis disconfirmation was not sufficient to warrant a convincing interpretation, however patterns of results were promising. Implications for theory, research and practice are discussed.

Item Type: Thesis - Honours
Authors/Creators:Port, MEH
Keywords: false admission, hypothesis disconfirmation, confession evidence, error sensitivity
Copyright Information:

Copyright 2016 the author

Item Statistics: View statistics for this item

Actions (login required)

Item Control Page Item Control Page