Open Access Repository

The efficacy of biological control agents of gorse, Ulex europaeus L., in Tasmania

Davies, JT 2006 , 'The efficacy of biological control agents of gorse, Ulex europaeus L., in Tasmania', PhD thesis, University of Tasmania.

PDF (Front Matter)
01front.pdf | Download (45kB)
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.

PDF (Whole Thesis)
02Whole.pdf | Download (2MB)
Available under University of Tasmania Standard License.


The primary aim of this study was to assess the individual impact of the gorse seed
weevil (Exapion ulicis), gorse spider mite (Tetranychus lintearius) and gorse thrips
(Sericothrips staphylinus) on the growth and development of gorse. Factors such as
natural enemy attack and herbicide use may affect biological control agent
populations and their resulting impact on the target weed. For this reason, the study
was extended to assess the potential impact of natural enemies on the gorse spider
mite and the gorse thrips and assess the toxicity of herbicides and adjuvants
commonly used for gorse control on the gorse thrips.The gorse spider mite caused a reduction in dry matter production of approximately
36% in a field experiment that compared mite-attacked plants to sprayed controls over
two and a half years. A threat to the effectiveness of this agent is predation by the
Chilean predatory mite, Phytoseiulus persimilis. An experiment showed this species
will develop at a similar rate on a diet of gorse spider mite as it would on the twospotted
mite, therefore confirming the ability of this species to have a negative impact
on gorse spider mite populations.
In a glasshouse experiment, gorse thrips, ryegrass competition and simulated grazing
individually reduced the growth of gorse seedlings. When treatments were combined,
survival of gorse seedlings was also reduced. These results suggest that this species
has the potential to be a useful biological control agent of gorse. However, as
population build up in the field has been slow, further studies on the biology and
ecology of this species are required. A field study was conducted to identify potential
natural enemies of the gorse thrips within the arthropod fauna inhabiting gorse. A range of species, including generalist predators, were identified. Of these, the
Phlaeothripid Haplothrips victoriensis and mites in the family Phytoseiidae were the
most abundant predatory arthropods present on gorse throughout the study and are
also reported to be natural enemies of other members of the family Thripidae. Further
studies are required to test the predatory efficacy of these arthropods on gorse thrips.
The gorse seed weevil was found to reduce seed production of gorse at two sites in
Tasmania. Due to pod production being continual at Lymington and only over spring
and summer at Stonehenge, the percentage of mature seed damaged in black pods for
the whole 20 months of sampling was 2.7 times higher at Stonehenge (45.5%) than at
Lymington (16.7%). On an annual basis, damage to mature seed at Stonehenge was
34.4% (2001/2002) and 55.4% (2002/2003) and at Lymington was 18.1%
(2001/2002) and 12.4% (2002/2003). Based on the results of this study and population
models produced elsewhere, it was concluded that additional seed feeding biological
control agents would be required to reduce seed production of gorse to below replacement levels.
A bioassay was conducted to determine the toxicity of herbicides and adjuvants
commonly used to control gorse on adult and juvenile gorse thrips. The herbicide
triclopyr/picloram was found to be consistently the most toxic chemical to both
juvenile and adult gorse thrips. Some toxicity was measured for the herbicide
glyphosate, the adjuvant modified polydimethylsiloxane and the adjuvant soyal
phospholipids/propionic acid. Metsulfuron methyl was not significantly toxic to either
adult or juvenile gorse thrips. Both adjuvants seemed to increase the toxicity of all the
herbicides on both juvenile and adult gorse thrips The integration of chemical and
biological control using the gorse thrips is discussed. Although each individual agent did have a measurable impact on certain aspects of
gorse performance, each had its limitations. Predation of the gorse spider mite by the
specialist predator, Phytoseiulus persimilis, is likely to limit its impact on gorse. The
gorse thrips did have an impact on gorse in a glasshouse environment but populations
have been slow to establish in the field and no evidence of an impact of this species
has been recorded five years after release. The gorse seed weevil does have an impact
on the production of gorse seed, however, the levels recorded in this study were not
enough to have an impact on gorse populations. The combined impact of these agents
on gorse populations was beyond the scope of this study, however, due to limitations
of each agent, it seems apparent that additional agents will be required if biological
control is to be considered an important long-term component of an integrated
management strategy for gorse.

Item Type: Thesis - PhD
Authors/Creators:Davies, JT
Keywords: Biological control, efficacy, Ulex europaeus, gorse, Exapion ulicis, gorse seed weevil, Tetranychus lintearius, gorse spider mite, Sericothrips staphylinus, gorse thrips, herbicide bioassay, Phytoseiulus persimilis, natural enemies, Tasmania
Item Statistics: View statistics for this item

Actions (login required)

Item Control Page Item Control Page